Book 2, Post 2
Book 2, Post 2
I chose the book, The Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom Matters in the Modern World by Wade Davis because I was interested in learning more about Polynesians' mastery of navigation across the Pacific Ocean. As someone from the islands, I've always had a strong interest in learning more about the history and culture of Pacific Islander communities to deepen my own understanding and engage more mindfully with these traditions. Although the book focuses largely on Polynesia, it still has strong correlations to the cultures in Micronesia and Melanesia. It truly is incredible that these islanders were able to navigate across the waters without any modern technology, only the stars, ocean currents, wind, and bird flight patterns.
I only read Chapter 2, The Wayfinders, from the book, mainly because I did not have enough time to read the rest. My review will be based solely on this chapter. Initially, I assumed this would be another Westernized perspective of the islands, focusing on how Europeans “discovered” them and viewed the people as “barbaric and uncivilized,” which I honestly thought was going to frustrate me. However, as I read more into the chapter, I was pleasantly surprised that the author gives credit where it’s due. The book highlights the incredible skill of the Polynesian navigators who traveled thousands of miles across the open ocean without modern technology, relying solely on their natural understanding of the world. Even as the Europeans studied the Polynesians’ navigation techniques, they still struggled to understand this incredible feat thousands of years ago.
One unique aspect of islander culture is that many of their teachings have been passed down through generations by word of mouth and hands-on experiences, with little written transcription. This method has been crucial for their cultural identity and resilience over the years.
However, there are broader implications of relying only on oral and hands-on traditions. The author discusses how Polynesian cultures face threats from colonialism, globalization, and assimilation. This doesn’t just apply to Polynesians, but Pacific Islanders as a whole. My CHamoru friends back home often talk about the growing concern that their culture and language are being forgotten. Many of the new generation cannot speak the language, nor do they know the history their grandparents know due to colonialism. This ties back to how important it is to recognize Pacific Islander heritage, not only for their cultural preservation but also to address modern issues.
I would recommend this book to others for the reasons mentioned above, but especially because it brings awareness to Pacific Islanders' culture and heritage so that they might not be forgotten in the near future.
It's amazing how Polynesians were able to travel the vast ocean without relying on modern on technology. I agree that it's very important to preserve cultures. It's a difficulty task, but hope every culture finds a way to preserve its knowledge as they are important for the entire humanity.
ReplyDeleteI also wanted to read this book, your review sounds interesting! I also find it fascinating how cultures were able to navigate in the past, I think it is so important to document and study those traditions. I feel you on the westernized perspective, often steers me away from reading a lot of books as well.
ReplyDeleteI also prioritized reading the second chapter of The Wayfinders and totally loved it! Thank you for drawing parallels between conversations with your friends back home and the concerns of lost culture in this book~ it made your analysis even more personal. I also enjoyed how you highlighted your first impressions of the book and initial thoughts on a potential Westernized perspective going into the reading assignment.
ReplyDeleteHi So Jung! This was such a good review for the chapters you got through! I like how you mentioned your connection to this story through friends and your childhood and told us why you chose this book! It's not the same thing, but I remember learning about oral and written history in Ancient Greece, and how islands were left vulnerable if they had little written history. This is a great story to share, and I'm honestly intrigued to hear more about it!
ReplyDeleteIt is fascinating how knowledge is passed down from generation to generation. It is devastating to see the aftermath of colonization and how it still affects many cultures. I have noticed this not only in our countries but also here in America. I have personally met a lot of people who are losing touch with their cultures, and it is sad to see how every generation is erasing the history of the previous ones.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was really cool how the book you chose to read really connected with you and your friends back home. I also do not really know too much about Pacific Islanders culture and it seems like I would really gain a lot from checking this book out. Appreciate the review!
ReplyDeleteSo Jung!!! This was such an excellent review. I really was on the fence between this book and the book I ended up choosing, and your review is making me think I should go back and read it! I really valued your note about minimal written transcriptions, I think about that a lot in regards to disappearing communities.
ReplyDelete